AJNS

NEUROEPIDEMIOLOGY / NEUROEPIDEMIOLOGIE
 
HOSPITAL BASED STUDY ON NEUROLOGICAL DISORDERS IN MADAGASCAR. DATA FROM THE NORTHWESTERN PART OF THE ISLAND



  1. Department of Neuropsychiatry, University Hospital, Mahajanga, Madagascar

E-Mail Contact - ANDRIANTSEHENO L. M. :


SUMMARY

Hospital-based data on neurological disorders from Mahajanga, the Northwestern province of Madagascar are reported. Epilepsies (28.75% of cases), chronic headaches (20.95%), peripheral neuropathies (13.75%) and stroke (11.30%) are the commonest illnesses encountered. Unlike western series, degenerative diseases and multiple sclerosis are unfrequent. The major risk factors (communicable diseases, malnutritions, poverty-induced stresses) and some aspects of the health care (lack of essential neurodiagnosis facilities and drugs) are shared with other developing tropical countries.


RESUME

Les auteurs rapportent les donnees hospitalieres sur les troubles neurologiques rencontres a Mahajanga, province occupant la partie Nord-ouest de Madagascar. Les epilepsies (28,75% des cas), les cephalees chroniques (20,95%), les neuropathies peripheriques (11,30%) constituent les affections les plus frequentes. Contrairement aux statistiques occidentales, les maladies degeneratives et la sclerose en plaques sont rares. Les principaux facteurs de risque (maladies transmissibles, manultrition, stress provoques par la pauvrete) et quelques aspects des realites sanitaires (manque d’equipments de diagnostic et de medicaments fondamentaux) sont partages avec d’autres pays tropicaux en voie de developpement.

Keywords : Epidemiology, Neurological diseases, Madagascar

INTRODUCTION

Tropical countries share common climatic and biologic characteristics. They are thus expected to disclose similar patterns of diseases. However, the prevalence of these diseases vary because of the development and of the sociocultural peculiarities of each country. Population-based studies, the most appropriate ones to assess the magnitude of each health problem are unavailable in Madagascar. We report hospital data from Mahajanga, a Northwestern region of the island.

STUDY POPULATION AND METHOD

The study population was expected to be that of the whole province (1,379,000 inhabitants), but in fact, only the population of the city of Mahajanga and its nearest surroundings (up to 200,000 inhabitants) had access to the University hospital.

The population was young (44<15 years-old, only 3,2/o>65 years-old), with an isosexual repartition expectancy (52 years vs 69 years for Mauritius) [1]. A considerable proportion of Mahajanga city dwellers have an Islamic influence, expressed in prohibitory eating behaviours (pork, alcoholic, drinks). The region has a hot and dry climate where malaria, schistosomiasis tuberculosis and syphilis are endemic.

The study itself consisted in a retrospective exam of registered inpatients and outpatients’ files in the department of Neuropsychiatry (University Hospital) between June 1, 1993 and December 31, 1995. Patients of both sexes, aged more than one year-old were included.

Electrical devices (EEG.EMG), cerebral imageries (CT scan, MRI), and sophisticated biological investigations were unavailable, so the diagnosis was built up on sole clinical and routine laboratory data. In fact, the most conclusive argument was the radical cure or alleviation of symptoms. The classification of the diseases was made according to internationally.recognised definitions (NINDS, IHS, ILAE, ICD 10).

RESULTS

1161 patients were registered during the study period: 741 had neurological disorders, 334 had psychiatric disorders, 86 had non neuropsychiatric diseases (table 1).

Table 1: Repartition of the diseases registered at the Departement of Neuropsychiatry during the study period.

Number(n) Percentage (%)
Total of cases 1161 100
Neurological diseases 741 63.85
Psychiatric diseases 334 28.75
Non neuropsychiatric diseases 86 7.4

Outpatients represented 68,42% of cases (n=507) and inpatients 31,58% of cases (n=234). Epilepsie were followed by chronic headaches, which were selectively recruited among outpatients, cerebrovascular diseases occupied the second place among inpatients; the real magnitude of this affection might be underevaluated, because of parallel recruitment in other wards. Unlike series from industrialised countries, degenerative diseases were rare. Peripheral neuropathies were common, whereas spastic paraparesis were of a minor concern. Two per cent (2%) of neuropathies (15/741) were inclassifiable because of tlie lack of specific investigations.

Table 2: Aetiological repartition of the neurological disease (in percentage) among all the patients, outpatients and inpatients.

Nature of the disease All Patients (n=741) All Patients (Rate %) Outpatients (n=507) Outpatients (Rate %) Inpatients (n=234) Inpatients (Rate %)
Epilepsies 213 28.75 161 31.75 52 22.22
Chronic headaches 155 20.95 150 29.58 5 2.13
Peripheral neuropathies 102 13.75 61 12.03 41 17.52
Cerebrovascular diseases 83 11.3 32 6.3 51 21.8
Infection of the CNS 69 9.35 24 4.75 45 19.24
Cerebral palsy 42 5.6 40 7.9 2 0.85
Degenerative diseases 26 3.5 8 1.58 18 7.7
Tumoral syndromes of the CNS 24 3.2 10 1.98 14 5.98
Sleep disorders 6 0.8 6 1.18 - -
Traumatic brain injuries 3 0.4 - - 3 1.28
Myopathies 3 0.4 - - 3 1.28
Unclassifiable disorder 15 2 15 2.9 - -

Epileptic seizures were listed in table 3: their classification, according to the 1981 ICE version was possible in spite of EEC data unavailability. Some authorities have admitted the validity of such classification (2,3). Like in most of tropical reports (3,4,5), partial seizures were predominant wheras absence seizures were underrated (1% vs 10% for GASTAUT’s [6]. Among the epilepsies which were deemed as secondary (56%=l 19/213), a putative aetiology was found in only 54% of them (64/119). Neurocystcercosis was the commonest pathology involved (42% of the aetiologies, i.e. 27/64). Phenobarbital was the drug of first choice (94% of the prescriptions). The other antiepileptic drugs were either unavailable, or too expensive.

Table 3: Distribution of the epileptic seizures according to the international Classification (ICES), 1981 version.

Seizure Type Number Rate (%)
Total 213 100
Unclassified seizure 5 2
Classifiable seizure 208 98
- Generalized seizures 97 47
Tonic clonic 89 43
Absence 2 1
Myoclonic 2 1
Others 4 2
- Partial seizures 111 53
Simple 42 20
Complex 10 5
Secondarily generalized 59 28

Chronic headaches were dominated by migraine (table 4); tension headaches were unexpectedly rare. Many physicians were still unfamiliar with migraine, as judged by the non negligible rate of diagnosis wanderings (spasmophilia, ocular dsyfunctions, sinusitis), and maladjusted prescriptions (preventive treatment prescribed for one month.). Long term management of migraine suffered from the same bad compliance than that encountered in epilepsies; the main reasons were unavailability or cost inaccessibility (in percentage).

Table 4: Aetiological repartition of the chronic headaches (in percentage).

Types of headaches Number Rate (%)
Total 155 100
Migraine 115 74.2
Psychiatriccephalalgia 10 6.45
Tension headache
- Chronic type 10 6.45
- Episodic type 7 4.5
- Symptomatic headaches 9 5.8
Cluster headache 2 1.3
Facial neuralgia 2 1.3

The aetiology investigations and the classification ofneuropathies (table 5) were limited by the lack of diagnosis facilities (EMG, nerve conduction studies, specific biologic dosages). The main putative cause asserted was polyvitamins deficiency (26% of cases, ie 27/102) within the frame of global malnutrition or alcoholism.

Heavy deficiency sufferers (e.g prisoners) sometimes disclosed aproximal hindlimbs involvement. Three cases were associated with heart failure (wet beriberi). Radicular compressions (mainly of the sciatic type) were surprisingly overrepresented in our series, whereas facial nerve palsy was unfrequent (8,82% of cases). Unlike some African countries (7), no HIV-related palsies were encountered. Mahajanga has a leprosarium, so only a typical manifestations of this infectious disease were addressed in our department (2,94% of cases).

Table 5: Repartition of the different anatomoclinical forms of neuropathies (in percentage).

Peripheral neuropathies Number Rate (%)
Total 102 100
Mononeuropathies 115 74.5
- Radicular compression 27 26.47
- Facial paralysis 9 8.82
- Plexus syndromes 4 3.92
- Entrapment neuropathies 4 3.92
Subacute or chronic polyneuropathies 34 33.33
Guillain-Barre syndromes 14 13.72
Mononeuropathies multiplex 5 4.9
Infection of Peripheral nerves (leprosy) 3 2.94
Myalgia syndromes 1 0.98
Optic Nerve atrophy 1 0.98

Like in the majority of Caucasian (8) and African studies (9,10), strokes were dominated by the ischemic type (table 6).

Table 6: Aetiological repartition of strokes (in percentage).

Strokes Number Rate (%)
Total 83 100
Ischemic strokes 53 64
Haemorrhagic strokes 15 18
Hypertensive encephalopathiy 5 6
Unclassified strokes 10 12

Hypertensive encephalopathy was screened with accuracy because of its better therapeutic issue. Hypertension and syphilis were the main risk factors identified. The global fatality rate was high (58% of cases, i.e. 48/83). Neurosisticercosis was at the head of CNS infections (table 7), although the anatomical specimen prevalence of this Parasitosis (II) was among the lowest in Mahajanga.(6/o vs 40% for Antananarivo, 32% for Tulear, 15% for Fianarantsoa). Diagnosis was made on sole clinical and serological basis (12); in fact, the therapeutic trial remained the most conclusive argument. Bacterial infections of the cerebrum and its coverings were surely underestimated because of parallel recruitments.

Table 7: Frequency of CNS infections (in percentage).

Infection of the CNS Number Rate (%)
Total 69 100
Neurocysticercosis 34 49
Meningitides, encephalomeningitides, brain abcess 16 23
Cerebral malaria 15 22
Neurosyphilis 4 6

Intrathecal antibiotics were often useful to palliate the dose inadequacy of parenteral drugs. Cerebral malaria, like in the other underdeveloped countries (13), provided a high fatality-rate (26% of case, ie 4/15), because of delayed chemotherapy. Neither HIV carriers nor proved quinine resistance was encountered among our fatal cases. Among degenerative affections. Parkinson’s disease was the most frequent. Parkinsonism related to chronic use of neuroleptics was far commoner. Alzheimer-type dementia was not yet a public health problem.

DISCUSSION

The data from Mahajanga, globally display the same patterns of neurological diseases as those found in the majority of tropical regions. In spite of the lack of population-based studies, the leading position of epilepsies among our hospital-registered cases confirm their importance in public health. The predominance of partial seizure parallels the high rate of secondary epilepsies. However, their pattern is not homogenous in different tropical countries: Nigerian studies (4) emphasize the causative role of febrile convulsions to explain the higher rate of complex partial seizures; on the contrary, Indian studies (5) yield a higher rate of partial simple seizures (58% of cases) and credit the prominent role of CNS infections, amongst which neurocysticercosis is paramount. Our pattern is of the Indian type (table 3) and this parasitosis, really plays an important role. Additional studies on risk factors, appropriate drug supply (14/15) and pertinent education of the population, are the most adapted means to fight against epilepsies.

Concerning chronic headaches, post graduate training is needed to improve the diagnosis and the management of the main aetiologic forms, viz migraine and headaches of psychological origin. Drugs availability and cost must be taken into account in case of long term treatment; patients compliance depend on these extramedical factors. Traditional pharmacopoeia (16) and alternative medicine (17) are optional or complementary issues for developing countries, but their use must be regulated. Peripheral neuropathies are probably underrated, for a bulk of patients to the hospital recruitment; the reasons may be a self management with vitamin and plants, geographical isolation and so on. The endowment of essential facilities (EMG, nerve conduction measurement, biological dosages) will enrich the knowledge about these diseases, common in tropical countries; certain aetiologies are likely different from those encountered in Western regions.

Massive polyvitamins deficiency is frequent among prisoners. Associated with a major protein calorie malnutrition it can provoke both axonal and segmental demyelination (18); this latter may explain the involvement of proximal hind-limbs in many patients. It is surprising to detect HTL V1 among Malagasy patients, for the Seychelles, which share the same climatic, ecological, and even cultural characteristics with Madagascar, are considered as endemic areas

The surprising high rate of nerve sciatic compression results likely on local inadequacy in professional training: indeed, Mahajanga is a port, and naive load handlers are recruited without any technical skill learning. However, lumbar disk prolapse is considered as a rather rare condition in Africans (20). Although the proportion of our stroke cases represent only one-third of those reported in the majority of African hospital-based studies (9,10,21,22), they constitute a real human and economic burden; the lack of appropriate diagnosis and therapeutic supplies may explain the high mortality rate, and the worse functional prognosis.

Global campaign against hypertension, the main risk factor, has proved to be an efficient method to decrease the secular trend of strokes (23,24). The infection of the CNS are by far the most important causes of mortality and mobidity in many African countries (25). Our data, probably underestimate their real importance, because of parallel recruitments. The prognosis is often worsened by the delayed management and by the incapacity in identifying and treating adequately the infectious agent. Like in other African series, degenerative diseases are rare, independently of the low life expectancy (26). Before concluding on a case of AIzheimer’s disease, tertiary syphilis and major depression must be ruled out.

CONCLUSION

The patterns ofneurological diseases in Mahajanga (Madagascar) are globally similar to that of the majority of tropical countries. A descriptive epidemiological survey on general population and epidemiological research on risk factors are basic to build up an appropriate preventive policy. Without an endowment of essential diagnosis facilities (EEG, EMG, Echography) and drugs, curative care would be inefficatious; this failure will reinforce the negative attitude of the population towards Western medicine and favour the action of quacks.

REFERENCES

  1. ANDRIAMBAO DS and the VC 101 study group, TEHINDRAZANARIVELO AD, ANDRIAMANTSIETIBENJA JJ, TSANGANDRAZANA. Incidence and mortality of stroke in Antananarivo, Madagascar, XII"’ Congress of the Pan African Association of Neurological Sciences, DURBAN, South Africa, May 1996.
  2. BELEC L, GHERARDI R, GEORGES AJ et al. Peripheral facial paralysis and HIV infection: report of four African cases and review of the literature. J. NEUROLOGY 1986;236:411-414.
  3. BWALA SA. Stroke in a subsaharian Nigerian hospital: a retrospective study. TROP DOC 1989;19:11-14.
  4. CHELLI S, CHELLI M. Approche epidemiologique des accidents vasculaires cerebraux. MAGHREB MED 1985; 109:26-31.
  5. CHOPRA JS, DHAD UK, METHA S et al.Effect of protein calorie manultrition on peripheral nerves. BRAIN 1986;109:307.
  6. COMMISSION OF EPIDEMIOLOGY AND PROGNOSIS OF THE INTERNATIONAL LEAGUE AGAINST EPILEPSY. Relationship between Epilepsy and Tropical diseases. EPILEPSIA 1994;35(l):89-93.
  7. COMMISSION ON EPIDEMIOLOGY AND PROGNOSIS OF THE INTERNATIONAL LEAGUE AGAINST EPILEPSY. Guidelines for epidemiologic studies on Epiepsy EPILEPSIA 1994; 34(4):592-596.
  8. COMMISSION ON CLASSIFICATION AND TERMINOLOGY OF THE INTERNATIONAL LEAGUE AGAINST EPILEPSY. Proposal for revised Classification and EEG. Classification of epileptic seizure. EPILEPSIA 1981;22:489-501.
  9. COSNET JE, BILL PL. Parkinson’s disease in Blacks. Observations on epidemiology in Natal. SOUTH AFR MED J. 1988.73:281-83.
  10. DANESI MA. Classification of the Epilepsies: an investigation of 945 patients in a developing country. EPILEPSIA 1985;26(2):131-136.
  11. DUMAS M, GIRAND PL, N’DIAVE IP, COLLOMB H. Accidents vasculaires cerebraux au Senegal. BULL SOCMEDAFR NOIRELANGFR 1973;18(3):265-277.
  12. Editorial. In the shadow of epilepsy. THE LANCET June 28 1997; vol 349(9069): 1851.
  13. ENDESHAW Y, TEKLEMAINOT R. Altered rate of consciousness in adult Ethiopian. analysis ofaetiological factors. J ROYAL SOC HEALTH 1988;5:173-175.
  14. GASTAUT H, GASTAUT JL, CONCALVES C et al. Relative frequency of different types of epilepsy: a study employing the Classification of the International League against Epilepsy. EPILEPSIA 1975;16:457-467.
  15. GIORNADO C, PIQUEMAL M, N’DZANGA E. Factuers de rique et frequence des infractus cerebraux chez ie Noir African de l’Ouest. MED &ARMEES 1979;7((4):355-358.
  16. HADDOCK DRW. Cerebrovascular accidents in Ghana. TRANS R. SOC TROP MED HYG.1970;64:300-310.
  17. JOSHI V, KATIYAR BC, MOHAN PK et al. Profile of epilepsy in a developing country: a study of 1,000 patients based on the International League against Epilepsy. EPILEPSIA 1977;18:549-554.
  18. LI S, SCHOENBERG BS, CHUNG-CHENG V, ct al. Epidemiology of epilepsy in urban areas of the People’s Republic of China. EPILEPSIA 1985;26:391-394.
  19. NIKIFOROW. Headache in a random sample of 200 persons: a clinical study of a population in Northern Finland. CEPHALALGIA 1981;1:97-107.
  20. OSUNTOKUN BO. Neurological disorders in Nigeria. In: SPILLANE TD ed: TROPICAL NEUROLOGY Oxford University Press, London 1973:161-190.
  21. PLACENTA M., SANDER JWAS, ROMAN M et al. The characteristics of epilepsy in a largely untreated population in rural Ecuador. J NEUROL NEUROSURG PSYCHIATRY1994;57:320-325.
  22. PROJECT PNUD/OPS, MAG/89/018. Regions et developpement: MAHAJANGA, DIRASSETed 1991.
  23. RASMUSSEN BK,JENSEN R, SCHROLL M, OLESEN J. Epidemiology of headache in a general population: a prevalence study. J CLIN EPIDEMIOL 1991 ;44:1147-1157.
  24. ROMAN GC, SCHOENBERG BS, MADDEN DL et al. Human-T lymphotropic virus type 1 antibodies in the serum of patients with tropical spastic paraparesis in the Seychelles. ARCHNEUROL 1987;44:605-607.
  25. SENANAYAKE N. Classification of epileptic seizures: a hospital-based study of 1,250 patients in a developing country. EPILEPSIA 1993;34(5):812-818.
  26. SCHOENBERG BS, KOKMEN E, OKAZAKI H. Alzheimer’s disease and other dementing illnesses in a defined United States population: incidence rates and clinical features. ANN NEUROL 1978,27-72.
  27. SCHOENBERG BS, OSUNTOKUN BO, ADEUJA AO et al. Comparison of the prevalence of Parkinson’s disease in Black population in the rural US and in rural Nigeria: door-to-door Community studies. NEUROLOGY 1988;38:645-646.
  28. TEKLE-HAIMANOT R. Parkinson’s disease in Ethiopia: a prospective study of 70 patients. EAST AFR MED J. 1985;62:571-579.
  29. VERNANT JC, MAURS L, GESSAINA et al. Endemic tropical spastic paraparesis associated with HTLV 1: a clinical and sero-epidemiological study of 25 cases. ANNNEUROL 1987-21:123-130.


© 2002-2012 African Journal of Neurological Sciences.
All rights reserved. Terms of use.
Tous droits réservés. Termes d'Utilisation.
ISSN: 1992-2647